• Home
  • About
  • Blog
  • Contact

Nancy Bailey's Education Website

Revive, Rally and Recover Public Schools

  • Activism
    • Anti-Charter Schools
    • Anti-Common Core State Standards
    • Anti-Corporatization of Schools
    • Anti-High-Stakes Testing
    • State Action Groups
    • School Buildings
  • School Curriculum
    • General Education
    • Educators
    • Parents
    • Reading
    • Writing
    • Math
    • Science
    • Social Studies
    • The Arts
    • Technology
    • Behavior
    • Diversity
    • English Language Learners
    • Special Education
      • Autism
      • Emotional and Behavioral Disabilities
      • Learning Disabilities
      • Developmental Disabilities
      • Gifted
      • Other
    • Early Childhood Education
    • Elementary School
    • Middle School
    • High School
    • Student Careers
  • Other Countries
    • England
    • Finland
    • Australia
    • New Zealand
    • Canada

Reading Instruction—Same Old Ugly Story

December 30, 2013 By Nancy Bailey 7 Comments

Post Views: 43

A conversation on Facebook about reading became touchy yesterday, reminding me that you only need to scratch the surface to find serious differences when it comes to education and public policy. While many come together against Common Core State Standards, yesterday’s arguing resulted from the same old differences about how to approach reading…phonics or whole language.

There are two camps: the phonics lovers who consider whole language to be the mark of the devil, and those who prefer whole language—a more natural approach to learning how to read.

There’s a third group too who want to criticize everything about public schools, claiming we have had a reading crisis on our hands forever. They like to use the argument that the lack of phonics has caused all the difficulties in public schools. The trouble with this argument is that phonics programs have dominated instruction in politics and most schools for many years. Children get exposed to phonics whether they need it or not. If phonics was the solution, one could ask, why are there still reading problems?

The trouble with the phonics/whole language argument is that there really should be no argument. At times phonics is appropriate. For students with dyslexia or certain other learning disabilities, a structured phonics program is critical. Some children without disabilities learn to read by sounding out words.

Other children don’t require phonics. They pick up reading naturally. They start school comfortable with reading—eager to do a lot of it. Learning to read comes easy to them.

There are also all kinds of in-between readers. Some might need a little phonics to help them sound out words for spelling and writing purposes, but they don’t require a highly structured phonics program. A little phonics for them goes a long way.

While children who require phonics should get it, children, who come to school reading well for their age, should not be forced to sit through endless structured phonics drill. It is a sure fire way to turn fluent readers against reading. What once was a joyful experience becomes drudgery!

It’s the lack of individualizing the needs of the student that is the real problem—sweeping all kids into a narrow plan to make education cheap and easy. Today’s message is to teach them all the same way…disregarding differences.

Children need distinct methods of instruction when learning how to read.  It takes professional judgment, well-prepared and credentialed reading teachers and parental involvement. It is all about individual evaluation and I don’t just mean testing here.

There are many ways to teach children how to read. Whether it is phonics, whole language, and/ or a little of both, one thing is for certain. Children require good community and school libraries with well-prepared certified librarians and a mix of old beloved stories and up-to-date fiction and nonfiction. It is essential that children get time to explore books for their enjoyment and are provided dedicated individuals who will read to them for fun.

The more a child is curious about books and/or stories, the more they will wish to read. Wanting to read is half the battle.

Prescriptive reading programs, where individualized reading needs are identified are what both parents and teachers desire. Smaller class sizes would help with this endeavor.

But one thing is certain. We need to end the either/or with the phonics and whole language argument. In part, it was a stirred up fight to help break up public schools. I will write about this another time.

Both approaches are important. Both phonics and whole language have their place at the table when it comes to the teaching of reading.

Filed Under: Common Core, Reading, Special Education Tagged With: books, Common Core, community libraries, credentialed librarians, credentialed teachers, dyslexia, fiction, learning disabilities, nonfiction, phonics, reading, school libraries, small class sizes, whole language

Comments

  1. Kimberly Kunst Domangue says

    December 30, 2013 at 7:32 pm

    thank you.

    Reply
  2. Jennifer McCann says

    January 2, 2014 at 4:18 pm

    While I do agree with your sentiments that literacy instruction cannot be all phonics or all whole language and must be differentiated for students to meet the many different needs in a classroom, I’m not sure where you got the impression that in our public schools, teaching reading is an either/or phonics or whole language situation. Metro Nashville Public Schools (where I am a literacy coach in an elementary school) adopted a balanced literacy framework over 10 years ago that acknowledges the need for a balanced approach to literacy, thus meeting the needs of different learning styles. Elementary teachers are required (and new teachers are trained) to teach reading and writing using this framework. Furthermore, elementary teachers administer a text-level assessment using a running record in which a student’s reading level is determined. Once text levels are determined, teachers are required to instruct students at their “instructional level” in small-group, guided reading instruction. This is in addition to the grade-level instruction that students would receive in whole-group “shared reading” scenarios. While trying to meet the individual needs of each student in a classroom is always challenging, your quote “today’s message is to teach them all in the same way…disregarding differences,” is simply not true. Differentiation is required by our district and supported through the assessments that determine individual reading and spelling levels (text-leveled assessment and developmental spelling assessment). Of course, I can only speak for the district in which I teach, but in Nashville, differentiation and a balanced approach to teaching literacy is the expectation for every classroom teacher.
    I want to make sure I am clear…I’m not arguing your point. I agree with your thoughts about what makes literacy instruction effective. I just wanted to share that there are districts where these best practices are being utilized.

    Reply
    • Nancy Bailey says

      January 2, 2014 at 8:52 pm

      Hi Jennifer, I appreciate your response and it sounds like you have quite a reading program going on there. It seems very measured. I’m wondering about the students who read well…how much free reading do they get and/or journal writing etc? I like much of what you mention though. Also, how is Common Core addressed and why are you called a coach and not a teacher? Thanks for taking the time to let me know more about Nashville’s reading program.

      Reply
  3. Betty Smith says

    January 3, 2014 at 12:05 pm

    http://improve-education.org/id46.html

    Reply
    • Betty Smith says

      January 3, 2014 at 12:06 pm

      “My guess is that Whole Word seemed to these educators the best device for forging children into a more homogeneous mass. In any event, phonics was scorned and Whole Word was king, through the Depression, World War II, and into the postwar boom. Dick and Jane readers were in every classroom; and all the problems that Dr. Orton discussed became commonplace.”

      Reply
    • pam says

      January 3, 2014 at 4:40 pm

      I love Bruce’s page. he works so hard to help kids read and shares the lie that is “Whole Word”

      Reply
  4. pam says

    January 3, 2014 at 3:20 pm

    Whole word was and is a complete nightmare!! It is the sole reason why we have millions of functional illiterates! Whole word was meant for the deaf not the hearing.When a child is told to “guess” or look for context clues just to be able to read, something is wrong! Balanced Lit is nothing more than another term for “Whole word” mixed with a little bit of phonics. Sounding out words makes a reader, not guessing and not be “Guided” what ever that means, LOL

    Reply

Leave a Reply to Kimberly Kunst Domangue Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

front cover

An education glossary with an attitude.

Buy Now

front cover

Do we really want an America where we no longer own our public schools?

Buy Now

front cover

This book says “no” to the reforms that fail, and challenges Americans to address the real student needs that will fix public schools and make America strong.

Buy Now

Follow me!

Enter your email address to subscribe to my blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Connect With Me!

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Nancy E. Bailey Follow

Longtime LD reading teacher, and other SPED areas. Author, Ph.D. Ed. Leadership, Blogging for Kids, and Democratic Public Schools.

NancyEBailey1
nancyebailey1 Nancy E. Bailey @nancyebailey1 ·
5h

Children must first learn reading is fun. Pushing phonics on young children means nothing if they can't connect it to the joy of reading. Jim Trelease knew the importance of reading aloud. His book holds the key.
https://nancyebailey.com/2022/08/17/reading-aloud-to-help-children-read-well-their-whole-lives/

Reply on Twitter 1559884690106064900 Retweet on Twitter 1559884690106064900 Like on Twitter 1559884690106064900 5 Twitter 1559884690106064900
Retweet on Twitter Nancy E. Bailey Retweeted
nicholasferroni Nicholas Ferroni @nicholasferroni ·
16 Aug

When you are trying to sell something that you know is not going to work… https://twitter.com/thehill/status/1558849930948534273

The Hill @thehill

.@GovDeSantis on recruiting veterans to the teaching field: "Our veterans have a wealth of knowledge and experience they can bring to bear in the classroom. [...] For too long, the requirements to be a teacher have been too rigid." https://trib.al/1bPu78k

Reply on Twitter 1559543217615278080 Retweet on Twitter 1559543217615278080 17 Like on Twitter 1559543217615278080 171 Twitter 1559543217615278080
Retweet on Twitter Nancy E. Bailey Retweeted
dey_project DEY.org @dey_project ·
1 Jul

The state of #recess in #america is horrendous. There are a few states where mandatory recess for K-8 have been achieved, but even there the minimum is too low. See @NancyEBailey1 post on recess: https://bit.ly/3bFyd6k.
#outdoorrecess #letthechildrenplay #playislearning

Reply on Twitter 1542885875545214976 Retweet on Twitter 1542885875545214976 2 Like on Twitter 1542885875545214976 2 Twitter 1542885875545214976
Retweet on Twitter Nancy E. Bailey Retweeted
plthomasedd Paul Thomas @plthomasedd ·
14 Aug

#jamesbaldwin

Reply on Twitter 1558816541734584321 Retweet on Twitter 1558816541734584321 4 Like on Twitter 1558816541734584321 3 Twitter 1558816541734584321
Retweet on Twitter Nancy E. Bailey Retweeted
msliteracy_mhs writeous teacher @msliteracy_mhs ·
13 Aug

Pre-K with a state-certified teacher should be a right, not a privilege.

Reply on Twitter 1558515590771490818 Retweet on Twitter 1558515590771490818 139 Like on Twitter 1558515590771490818 1796 Twitter 1558515590771490818
Load More

Archives

Tag Cloud

Arne Duncan Autism Betsy DeVos Bill Gates charter schools class size Common Core Common Core covid-19 disabilities dyslexia early childhood education Education Secretary Betsy DeVos Florida high-stakes testing inclusion kindergarten learning disabilities mental health Online Learning parents Personalized Learning phonics preschool private schools privatization public schools reading recess School Choice school libraries School Privatization school reform Social Emotional Learning special education students Students with Disabilities Teacher Preparation teachers Teach for America teaching Technology testing the arts vouchers

Copyright © 2022 Nancy E. Bailey · Website powered by Standing Pine Media.