• Home
  • About
  • Blog
  • Contact

Nancy Bailey's Education Website

Revive, Rally and Recover Public Schools

  • Activism
    • Anti-Charter Schools
    • Anti-Common Core State Standards
    • Anti-Corporatization of Schools
    • Anti-High-Stakes Testing
    • State Action Groups
    • School Buildings
  • School Curriculum
    • General Education
    • Educators
    • Parents
    • Reading
    • Writing
    • Math
    • Science
    • Social Studies
    • The Arts
    • Technology
    • Behavior
    • Diversity
    • English Language Learners
    • Special Education
      • Autism
      • Emotional and Behavioral Disabilities
      • Learning Disabilities
      • Developmental Disabilities
      • Gifted
      • Other
    • Early Childhood Education
    • Elementary School
    • Middle School
    • High School
    • Student Careers
  • Other Countries
    • England
    • Finland
    • Australia
    • New Zealand
    • Canada

Common Core Creator Slammed Reading Teachers for Having a Research Gap—How Ironic

November 29, 2018 By Nancy Bailey 3 Comments

Post Views: 263

Teachers have enough difficulties. Sometimes you find an article so full of hubris and irony it cannot be ignored.

Several weeks ago, I criticized a series of reports about reading by journalist Emily Hanford. Hanford claimed teachers didn’t understand reading instruction and that their education schools failed to teach them what they should know.

I made the case that these reports involved poor arguments. The author cited the flawed National Reading Panel report and the National Council on Teacher Quality a think tank meant to discredit teachers.

It seemed like the underlying goal was to pit parents against teachers.

That’s not to say that there isn’t a discussion to be had about reading instruction in public schools, only that Hanford’s articles were promoting corporate reform, however nuanced.

I overlooked an Ed. Week article by Susan Pimental, an architect of Common Core English language arts. Pimental praises Hanford’s articles. She criticizes teachers for failing to do necessary reading research to effectively teach reading.

I’m struck by how strange and bold that claim is from someone tied to Common Core State Standards.

Who researched Common Core before forcing teachers to adopt the standards in their classrooms? Pimental who has a bachelor’s degree in early childhood education (I don’t know if she taught) and is a lawyer, is no reading expert.

Despite Pimental’s early childhood degree, Common Core for the youngest learners are criticized as failed standards.

Here’s Pimental’s bio from Ed. Week.

Susan Pimentel is a co-founder of the StandardsWork and a founding partner of Student Achievement Partners, both nonprofits dedicated to improving K-12 student achievement through evidence-based action. She was the lead author of the Common Core State Standards for English/language arts literacy.

But let’s look specifically at her criticism of teachers and public schools.

  1. Children are put in reading groups. Many schools group students after assessment by Response to Intervention. Pimental doesn’t mention RTI. She is simply critical of the groups. Many worry that RTI is meant to replace special education. She doesn’t mention that either.
  2. There’s not enough content knowledge. Why is there not enough social studies, science, and the arts? The emphasis on reading came about with NCLB and the push to raise test scores. Common Core focused on ELA and math. They neglected the other subjects too. Now they push Next Generation Science, but how many students missed out on valuable subject matter in other areas due to Common Core’s narrowness?
  3. The curriculum is poor quality. She blames the lack of phonics for reading problems. How many schools do not teach any phonics? The real argument is how much phonics, for whom, and when.

What’s especially bizarre is that Common Core has been around for years. Sadly, many teachers in good faith, tried to wrap their teaching around those objectives when it came to English and language arts.

So, if students are not doing well learning how to read, maybe we should look at Pimental and her Common Core friends. If teachers aren’t measuring up when it comes to reading instruction, let’s criticize Common Core State Standards!

Why would Pimental tread into this territory? Her praise of Hanford’s articles provides further evidence that those articles were never about healthy debate surrounding reading instruction.

There’s a discussion that should take place about how reading should be taught. But that debate needs to be between teachers and parents at local school districts and within the classroom for individual children.

It would be nice to also hear more from reading professors. [What a great coincidence! NEPC just published this about the Reading Wars by Elizabeth Moje, Dean of the University of Michigan School of Education.]

Improving reading instruction is not resolved by unjustified accusations of teachers and their colleges of education by reformers far removed from the classroom.

Filed Under: Featured Tagged With: Colleges of Education, Common Core, Emily Hanford, phonics, reading, Reading Instruction, Susan Pimental

Comments

  1. John A Stewart says

    November 29, 2018 at 3:55 pm

    I agree that there is a lot to be explored when it comes to how particular school districts and particular schools are implementing their reading strategy. A strategy probably sounds pretty good on paper, but it may not be carried out with fidelity. Or even more likely, the school district never had the money to carry it out with fidelity. Or the students don’t have the support at home to exploit the strategy to their advantage.

    Reply
    • Nancy Bailey says

      November 30, 2018 at 6:30 am

      Great points! Thank you for sharing, John.

      Reply

Trackbacks

  1. Common Core Creator Slammed Reading Teachers for Having a Research Gap—How Ironic | IEA Voice says:
    December 5, 2018 at 3:47 am

    […] Source: Common Core Creator Slammed Reading Teachers for Having a Research Gap—How Ironic […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

front cover

An education glossary with an attitude.

Buy Now

front cover

Do we really want an America where we no longer own our public schools?

Buy Now

front cover

This book says “no” to the reforms that fail, and challenges Americans to address the real student needs that will fix public schools and make America strong.

Buy Now

Follow me!

Enter your email address to subscribe to my blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Connect With Me!

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Nancy E. BaileyFollow

SPED Teacher, Author, PhD Ed. Leadership, Blogging for Kids, and Democratic Public Schools that should belong to all of us.

Nancy E. Bailey
Retweet on TwitterNancy E. Bailey Retweeted
lauranbowmanLaura Bowman@lauranbowman·
14h

Cherry-picking data to undermine schools 90% of us send our kids to & privatize for profit. Way to further demoralize an already beaten-down workforce & push for EVEN MORE standardized testing & data collection. Nothing new & exciting. Sounds so very dreary/ punitive/out-of-touch https://twitter.com/roanoketimes/status/1527313907034910721

The Roanoke Times@roanoketimes

Virginia's K-12 school performance is backsliding due to reduced expectations for students and schools and a lack of transparency, resulting in widening achievement gaps, according to a critical new assessment from Virginia's superintendent of publi… https://roanoke.com/news/state-and-regional/youngkin-administration-report-finds-alarming-trends-in-virginias-k-12-performance/article_2e6f32bb-878b-5d05-b900-9b6ce2b41860.html?utm_campaign=blox&utm_source=twitter&utm_medium=social

Reply on Twitter 1527429346696343553Retweet on Twitter 15274293466963435537Like on Twitter 152742934669634355310Twitter 1527429346696343553
Retweet on TwitterNancy E. Bailey Retweeted
cherkiesCheri Kiesecker@cherkies·
18h

Interesting. Wonder how the USDOE Office of Edtech will incorporate FTC's new COPPA policy statement. "Students must be able to do their schoolwork without surveillance by companies"
https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2022/05/ftc-crack-down-companies-illegally-surveil-children-learning-online https://twitter.com/EdScoop_news/status/1527373549198946327

EdScoop News@EdScoop_news

The Office of EdTech is updating its national edtech plan, the strategy document outlining how technology is used in U.S. education @OfficeofEdTech https://edscoop.com/national-edtech-plan-2022-refresh/

Reply on Twitter 1527380243178082310Retweet on Twitter 15273802431780823109Like on Twitter 15273802431780823105Twitter 1527380243178082310
Retweet on TwitterNancy E. Bailey Retweeted
plthomasEdDPaul Thomas@plthomasEdD·
23h

Media and Political Misreading of Reading (Again): NYC Edition http://radicalscholarship.com/2022/05/19/media-and-political-misreading-of-reading-again-nyc-edition/

Reply on Twitter 1527297911054159873Retweet on Twitter 15272979110541598732Like on Twitter 15272979110541598731Twitter 1527297911054159873
Retweet on TwitterNancy E. Bailey Retweeted
NancyEBailey1Nancy E. Bailey@NancyEBailey1·
18 May

@PennBat I worry that many students with disabilities will miss out on inclusion classes with their non-disabled peers with vouchers. The best they will find are segregated charters or private schools that only focus on the disability.

Reply on Twitter 1527060376814231556Retweet on Twitter 152706037681423155610Like on Twitter 152706037681423155616Twitter 1527060376814231556
Retweet on TwitterNancy E. Bailey Retweeted
PennBatPA BATs R Pro Charter Reform@PennBat·
18 May

1. You lost
2. Where are the Special Ed students supposed to go when all the public schools are gone and voucher schools won't accept them?

"School Choice" isn't for ALL kids. Anyone who says it is, is full of 💩 https://twitter.com/DeAngelisCorey/status/1513571301155348481

Corey A. DeAngelis@DeAngelisCorey

@RepKrajewski the money doesn't belong to the government schools.

education funding is meant for educating children, not for protecting a particular institution.

we should fund students, not systems.

Reply on Twitter 1527046639420157952Retweet on Twitter 15270466394201579526Like on Twitter 152704663942015795212Twitter 1527046639420157952
Load More...

Archives

Tag Cloud

Arne Duncan Autism Betsy DeVos Bill Gates charter schools class size Common Core Common Core covid-19 disabilities dyslexia early childhood education Education Secretary Betsy DeVos Florida high-stakes testing kindergarten learning disabilities Online Learning parents Personalized Learning phonics preschool private schools privatization public schools reading recess retention School Choice school libraries School Privatization school reform schools Social Emotional Learning special education students Students with Disabilities Teacher Preparation teachers Teach for America teaching Technology testing the arts vouchers

Copyright © 2022 Nancy E. Bailey · Website powered by Standing Pine Media.