• Home
  • About
  • Blog
  • Contact

Nancy Bailey's Education Website

Revive, Rally and Recover Public Schools

  • Activism
    • Anti-Charter Schools
    • Anti-Common Core State Standards
    • Anti-Corporatization of Schools
    • Anti-High-Stakes Testing
    • State Action Groups
    • School Buildings
  • School Curriculum
    • General Education
    • Educators
    • Parents
    • Reading
    • Writing
    • Math
    • Science
    • Social Studies
    • The Arts
    • Technology
    • Behavior
    • Diversity
    • English Language Learners
    • Special Education
      • Autism
      • Emotional and Behavioral Disabilities
      • Learning Disabilities
      • Developmental Disabilities
      • Gifted
      • Other
    • Early Childhood Education
    • Elementary School
    • Middle School
    • High School
    • Student Careers
  • Other Countries
    • England
    • Finland
    • Australia
    • New Zealand
    • Canada

DeVos and False Claims of Failed Schools: How School Reform Hurts Children

March 1, 2017 By Nancy Bailey 4 Comments

Post Views: 8

The conviction that the best way to prepare children for a harsh, rapidly changing world is to introduce formal instruction at an early age is wrong. There is simply no evidence to support it, and considerable evidence against it. Starting children early academically has not worked in the past and is not working now.

—David Elkind, Professor of Child Development and author of Reinventing Childhood and The Hurried Child   

School reform, the underhanded drive to privatize education into free market, choice schools (many profitmaking), has had a negative effect on children and their development.

Here is the most recent research by Stanford researcher Martin Carnoy who analyzed 25 years of research and found that voucher programs do not significantly improve test scores. Carnoy says vouchers distract from proven policies and programs with proven impact on test scores and graduation rates.

By claiming that public schools are the “status quo” (often stated by DeVos and other school reformers) it is implied that they failed, along with the children in them.

This is a false argument. It is used to condemn public education. Even though public schools are sorely underfunded, especially poor public schools, many of them still succeed!

Most of us know that even when public schools improve their test scores, the school reformers up the ante and their claims are that children still aren’t doing well enough when it comes to learning.

So, in order to condemn public schools, children are pushed harder, lose out on the arts and other important subjects, miss recess, and a whole lot of other learning experiences that make for quality instruction.

School reformers, who, like Betsy DeVos, have never been teachers and know little about child development, hurt children—even though they might think they are helping them.

Condemning public schools we hear the repeated claim that children fail. Public schools and teachers are blamed.

But children also hear these messages:

  • You fail to keep up.
  • You fail at testing.
  • You fail at reading.
  • You fail at history.
  • You fail to behave.
  • You fail at STEM.
  • You fail to stay on task.
  • You fail to graduate.
  • You fail to pay attention.
  • You fail to ask questions.
  • You fail to complete school.
  • You fail to attend college.
  • You fail to have grit.
  • You fail to do rigorous work.

And on it goes.

Children are said to fail in their public schools when they have not failed!

But this message is used to not only shutter public schools and condemn teachers, but to push students to learn faster—beyond their age and development.

If children are taught they are failing, the only way out is to work harder and faster and learn more!

School reformers like to associate this false school failure with the economy, when we all know that children and their public schools have had nothing to do with the problems found in the economy.

Yet here we are. Without any regulations to stop school reformers like DeVos, and there have been many before her, from interfering with public education, now kindergarten is called the new first grade.

Early childhood experts know that when young children miss out on the conditions and activities critical for growth and development at this age it will have repercussions.

Yet, school reformers have been permitted to use this failure message, not only to push children,  but to transform schools into all-technology and other privatization ventures.

Their school reforms have little backup when it comes to real research.

This can’t help but change children and not in a good way.

For example, according to the Alliance for Childhood, we’ve known since 2000 that too much computer use with children is a hazard. We’ve also known about testing causing stress in children.

And children are still denied play. How does that affect them?

Consider that, in the 1940s, if you took a 3-year-old, a 5-year-old, and 7-year-old and asked them to stand still, the 3 year old could not stand still long. The 5-year-old could stand still a little longer, but not by much.

The 7-year-old, however, could stand still for a long time.

In 2001, when psychologists replicated this experiment, they got different results.

They found that the 7-year-olds couldn’t stand still any longer than a 5-year-old could in the 1940s. The 5-year-old was like a 3-year-old and couldn’t stand still at all.

This was a study done by psychologists at the Mid-Continent Research for Education and Learning described in a 2008 NPR report.

How children learn matters to their development.

When children are told they are failures, and when they are pushed to learn beyond their development, when activities like play are taken out of a young child’s life, there will be consequences.

In the next few weeks I will be especially looking at research to find how school reform has impacted young children—their behavior and their learning ability.

If you run across studies of this nature, or feel comfortable sharing a personal experience, it would be appreciated. I will give you credit, or you can remain anonymous.

Thank you.

If you want to learn new insight about how we came to this point of losing our public schools, check out my recent book.

Or, the older one. HERE.

Filed Under: Featured Tagged With: Betsy DeVos, child development, curriculum, early childhood education, False Claims About Public Schools, play, School Privatization, Technology

Comments

  1. karafree says

    March 2, 2017 at 9:08 am

    Honestly, this is so sad, I would go as far as to say that the misguided education program taking over our schools is a form of abuse against our precious young. The list of (non) failures, taking away the child’s most productive means of learning thru play, imagination, independent investigation in the outdoors, freedom to move and exercise, children learn who they are by discovering through play, they ask questions and become curious because they are out there discovering the world and how they fit in with it… To be taught at the get go that one is failing is a travesty… and why? Does it really come down to the almighty dollar? I wish everyone could read this article and really see what is going on.

    Reply
    • Nancy Bailey says

      March 2, 2017 at 9:58 am

      I agree it is abuse, Kara. Not giving children breaks throughout the day is just a part of it. Parents begging for 20 minutes of freedom from draconian schedules that drive children out of the arts and anything non-academic…how does that happen?

      Thank you.

      Reply
  2. ciedie aech says

    March 2, 2017 at 11:59 am

    A terribly sad connected truth is that too many experienced teachers have either been forced out of their classrooms with the claim of having produced “low” test scores, or they have chosen to leave teaching due to the nation’s pull away from child-protective teaching. The kids have no self-advocacy and each year, now, they have less and less teacher advocacy.

    Reply
    • Nancy Bailey says

      March 3, 2017 at 6:59 am

      Sad but true. Thank you, Ciedie.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

front cover

An education glossary with an attitude.

Buy Now

front cover

Do we really want an America where we no longer own our public schools?

Buy Now

front cover

This book says “no” to the reforms that fail, and challenges Americans to address the real student needs that will fix public schools and make America strong.

Buy Now

Follow me!

Enter your email address to subscribe to my blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Connect With Me!

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Nancy E. Bailey Follow

SPED Teacher, Author, PhD Ed. Leadership, Blogging for Kids, and Democratic Public Schools that should belong to all of us.

NancyEBailey1
Retweet on Twitter Nancy E. Bailey Retweeted
susanoha Susan Ohanian @susanoha ·
10h

Hillsdale College is involved in the development of teacher training materials.

https://www.tampabay.com/news/florida-politics/2022/06/28/some-teachers-alarmed-by-florida-civics-training-approach-on-religion-slavery

Reply on Twitter 1543308765323223043 Retweet on Twitter 1543308765323223043 2 Like on Twitter 1543308765323223043 1 Twitter 1543308765323223043
Retweet on Twitter Nancy E. Bailey Retweeted
daschwartzy Danielle Schwartz @daschwartzy ·
16h

Will parents demand real teachers or buy the online sales pitches? @NancyEBailey1 nails it. https://twitter.com/NEPCtweet/status/1542923534736838656

NEPC @NEPCtweet

"There’s little proof online programs will provide all that a child needs to become a good reader." @NancyEBailey1 https://bit.ly/3bKb5Uj

Reply on Twitter 1543220509999075330 Retweet on Twitter 1543220509999075330 3 Like on Twitter 1543220509999075330 7 Twitter 1543220509999075330
Retweet on Twitter Nancy E. Bailey Retweeted
nepctweet NEPC @nepctweet ·
1 Jul

"There’s little proof online programs will provide all that a child needs to become a good reader." @NancyEBailey1 https://bit.ly/3bKb5Uj

Reply on Twitter 1542923534736838656 Retweet on Twitter 1542923534736838656 3 Like on Twitter 1542923534736838656 4 Twitter 1542923534736838656
Retweet on Twitter Nancy E. Bailey Retweeted
norinrad10 TC Weber @norinrad10 ·
1 Jul

Have a safe Fourth while you enjoy the latest from Dad Gone Wild...https://wp.me/p4d08y-3fj @ChalkbeatTN @Tennessean @TNEdReport @TNedu @MetroSchools @palan57 @DianeRavitch

Reply on Twitter 1542918904208670723 Retweet on Twitter 1542918904208670723 5 Like on Twitter 1542918904208670723 1 Twitter 1542918904208670723
Retweet on Twitter Nancy E. Bailey Retweeted
arizona_sos Save Our Schools AZ @arizona_sos ·
1 Jul

Betsy DeVos’ American Federation for Children (AFC) is *already* using predatory tactics to advertise vouchers in AZ even before Gov. Ducey signs #HB2853 (universal vouchers) into law.

What they fail to mention is that voucher schools can legally discriminate against kids 😡

Reply on Twitter 1542716727787606016 Retweet on Twitter 1542716727787606016 67 Like on Twitter 1542716727787606016 89 Twitter 1542716727787606016
Load More

Archives

Tag Cloud

Arne Duncan Autism Betsy DeVos Bill Gates charter schools class size Common Core Common Core covid-19 dyslexia early childhood education Education Secretary Betsy DeVos Florida high-stakes testing kindergarten learning disabilities Online Learning parents Personalized Learning phonics preschool private schools privatization public schools reading Reading Instruction recess retention School Choice school libraries School Privatization school reform schools Social Emotional Learning special education students Students with Disabilities Teacher Preparation teachers Teach for America teaching Technology testing the arts vouchers

Copyright © 2022 Nancy E. Bailey · Website powered by Standing Pine Media.